The Grandmothers on how and when to say, "Good Job!!!"
“100 Ways to Say ‘Good Job!’” the heading on the sheet of stickers says, and then all 100, from “Awesome” to “Zero Mistakes,” appear with accompanying smiley faces and abundant exclamation points. These are sold to teachers as self-esteem promoters. Everyone, teachers and children alike, know them to be artificial at best, but at least they are evidence of the general awareness that self-esteem is an important commodity.
But self-esteem is not so easily created, and certainly not when imposed from without. Self-esteem by definition has to grow from within. Students who receive praise for work they know full well to be less than their best feel worse about themselves, in fact, not better, when they hear a perfunctory “Good job!” Older students feel dismissed, unworthy of a more time-consuming and honest critique of their efforts. Younger ones just feel vaguely guilty.
THE PHONY PRAISE TRAP
It’s all too easy to fall into the phony “Good job!” trap. If the admiration is sincere, the child senses that. If he distrusts the praise, however, he will feel not encouraged but manipulated. And if he grows to depend on the adult for confirmation that he’s done a “good job,” then he has not gained in self-esteem.
Sometimes, in fact, words are unnecessary. If a child is absorbed in a project, he might well feel interrupted, even patronized, if an adult bursts in with effusive burbles and coos. It’s perfectly OK to just smile and nod, and then go about one’s business as the child continues with his, permitting his satisfaction to come from within.
If words are called for, however, better than “Good job!” might be the words,“You must feel good about being able to climb up to the top of that climber. You have been working hard at that. Last week you had to stop halfway up and now you’re at the very top.” The child will benefit from hearing what exactly is being admired, and also from reflecting on how he feels about his accomplishment, not how the adult feels. You certainly don’t want him to start doing a “good job” only to win your praise; you want him to do a good job for the job’s sake, for his own inner satisfaction.
SELF-ESTEEM OBSTACLES
But what if he sincerely tries, and sincerely fails? What if the climber is just too high or the math problem is simply too difficult, and he comes to you wailing his discouragement? Then the admiring adult is called upon to notice the effort and intent, the tiny steps that might in time lead to an accomplishment of the difficult task, and admire those. In fact, the parent has every reason to admire persistence and patience more than the completion of a difficult task. In psychological tests, children have been observed increasing their efforts when it was their persistence that was praised, rather than their successes.
And then there’s the matter of what you say when the first words that pop into your head aren’t “Good job!” but “Terrible job!” The toys he promised to pick up are still scattered where he left them, or he gave himself a disastrous haircut with the scissors he wasn’t supposed to touch. If you tell him of your displeasure, will he have a permanently damaged self-esteem? Of course not. In fact, the spirit of “terrible job” – although perhaps not those exact words – is the message you want to convey, as opposed to “terrible kid.” If you can keep your wits about you, you might follow the format recommended for admiring his successes: tell him exactly what he did that distressed you, and then suggest that probably he feels bad about what he did and will feel better if he can make amends somehow. And then help him find a way to do that. He could get to work picking up those toys, or sweep up the hair that’s strewn all over the bathroom floor.
PARENTS’ SELF-ESTEEM
Our own self-esteem is involved, in fact, in whether or not our child can climb to the top of the climber, get an A on that homework assignment, or go all day without pooping in his pants. We would do well to remind ourselves that while our approval or disapproval is enormously important to our children, we should resist letting our own self-esteem be dependent on our children’s accomplishments. Instead we can be proud of helping our kids own their own successes and failures, without looking to us for the ultimate judgment.
If you have a parenting question, please email it to us at thegrandmothers@collinwoodobserver.com. Or mail it to The Grandmothers, Collinwood Observer, 650 E. 185th St., Cleveland, OH 44119.
The Grandmothers are Kathy Baker, Maria Kaiser, Gann Roberts and Ginny Steininger. They meet at Hanna Perkins Center, 19901 Malvern Road, which houses the Hanna Perkins School and the Reinberger Parent/Child Resource Center. For information call Barbara Streeter (216) 991-4472.